Nonprofit Direct Mail Fundraiser Response Rate 

A nonprofit direct mail fundraiser response rate does not tell you how much money you made or lost, nor does it tell you how much you spent per dollar or donation. The response rate tells you how many people responded to your fundraising mailing, but it doesn’t tell you whether or not your direct mail fundraising effort was a success.

(Looking for non profit bulk mailing? Contact us today!)

Renewal mailings generate higher response rates 

Nonprofit direct mail fundraisers that use renewal mailings are more likely to achieve higher response rates than those that do not. This strategy is most effective if your nonprofit has a high retention rate and an active donor base. This type of mailing allows your nonprofit to retain a large number of donors while also acquiring new ones. For example, consider an organization that has 5,000 donors and sends four solicitations per year. On average, each of those donors gives one gift. If only 40 percent of donors respond, that means you must send four solicitations each year to achieve a 60% renewal rate. If you send four mailings per year, you will receive less than half your donors’ gifts. 

Renewal mailings are generally more effective than acquisition mailings because they target donors who have given before. Since the donor already knows your nonprofit, they will be more likely to make a gift to your nonprofit in the future. The average response rate for a renewal mailing is five percent to 35 percent, which is significantly higher than the response rate for a new acquisition mailing. 

Communicate your real need in a direct and honest way 

Direct mail is an effective way to raise funds for nonprofits. Unlike e-mails, it has a high response rate and can provide more information about donors. You can even rent mailing lists from larger organizations. Direct mail can also be more personal and communicate your real need clearly and honestly. 

To raise funds through direct mail, nonprofits must be able to convey a deep sense of respect. Donors should not be insulted or manipulated. Don’t exaggerate the urgency of the need, nor should you use stories or images that may scare donors. Tell a personal story and use humanizing details. 

Integrate your marketing touchpoints 

Direct mail is an effective tool for reaching donors, potential donors and repeat donors. Its target audience is typically adults with discretionary income, and it’s an old-fashioned method of fundraising that reaches a generation that enjoys the touch and feel of a physical letter. Even digitally-savvy donors appreciate the sense of intimacy that comes from receiving the printed paper. 

When using direct mail, it’s best to integrate it with other marketing touchpoints. For example, if you combine direct mail with digital ads, the response rate will be more than double that of direct mail alone. This approach is known as multi-touch marketing, and it builds stronger relationships with donors over time. 

Track retention rates 

If you want to improve your donor retention rates, you need to take a data-driven approach. You must not rely on intuition or gut feeling. Instead, you should make use of data to formulate a retention policy that will benefit your nonprofit. This will help you to understand your donors and better tailor your fundraising campaigns. 

The retention rate of a donor can tell you whether your nonprofit is attracting new donors or retaining existing ones. Recurring donors are more likely to continue to give than new ones, which means they require less of a financial incentive. Nonprofits can calculate their retention rate by dividing the number of recurring donors by the total number of donors. Then, multiply this number by 100 to get the percentage.